I'd label myself an intermediate/beginner to 3D art and I found the tutorial to be very informative and well laid out. Thank you. My only want for the tutorial would be two images on page nine. One showing the final lighting effect as you have now, but another showing the placement of those lights. I realize this wasn't a lighting tutorial, but page nine just looks a bit like a magician saying, "Now that you can all see the Eiffel Tower, work on making it disappear. Like so." poof "See?" Don't get me wrong, I really appreciate the tutorial, and the magician simile is meant wholey as a compliment, because that is definitely what it appears to be from page 8 to 9; magic. This is a fantastic image as usual for you.