Not a bad idea at all! I'd recommend having three separate (sp?) galleries: General Gallery - anyone can post here, comments, ratings enabled at the poster's option, but only for "finished" works. Premium Gallery - as listed above, but with no ratings, only comments, and these enabled at the poster's option. WIP Gallery - for Works In Progress, with comments ALWAYS enabled (that is kind of the point of posting a WIP, after all!), and ratings optional.