I like the idea of a "Critique Genre", this would give us the chance to improve by help from our peers that we don't get too often in the regular galleries. If I want input on an image I usually post in the forum but recently there was a comment from derjimi that images should not be posted in the forum because it was a form of spam and I guess to a point he's right but how else do you get the constructive critisism you want. If there was even a WIP forum just for posting images and receiving critisism that would be a good way to receive comments. This problem has been on my mind for some time now and I too was going to post a thread about it so I'm very happy that you brought this to the communities attention tuttle. Catlin