Sorry, but I still would have to go with a critique forum, not a gallery genre, although I still wouldn't mind an icon and/or text in the comment box of people who wanted a certain type of comment. Believe me, critique forums do get traffic. Then after your pic has been critiqued to death, you can always post in the gallery. I really do think that the line should not be blurred in the galleries as to what wants to be critiqued and what people think should be critiqued. There is enough of that already. Let us not forget as well Tuttle, that changes made here affect everyone, so the question is not whether you would use such a forum, the question is, would people use it in general...

Course, honestly, I still don't see why one can't just request in bold letters, which seems to work very well, what they want their comments to be...

ShadowWind