Some of this sounds like the Purists vs Impurists debate. If you do too much photoshop postwork then the Bryce anti postwork squad gets pissed. Funny that the Poser gallery has the purist vs impurist debates too. Looks like each gallery has its zone and it does not like intruders. Need to have lighting, texturing and composition done right for a good picture. A picture with good lighting but crappy textures or composition, is not going to go anywhere.