TMGraphics, if it's the RK I'm thinking of, I disagree. I started to list the differences but suffice it to say, the style isn't the same IMHO. Thie mods would have had to kill this thread by now if that were the case :-) I agree that perhaps critiques should be private (depends on how the recipient feels), but I seriously doubt that any of the personas here would let their opinion of a piece be influenced by someone elses. Of course, I don't know how many people here went to see Gigli. I do love the review by one critic who said that after watching Gigli, he had to cleanse his palate by watching Glitter. Tigershark's bite can't possibly be that bad.

"Democracy is a pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance." - H. L. Mencken