"...on the point of a critics corner. It would only be used by those peeps who dont mind constructive criticism now..." That's the idea. , to help the people who genuinely want to hear the truth (or a reasonable facsimilie therof), to help them improve. It would be wasted on the others anyway. I also think that dlk30341 has a good point. I would think that anyone interested in art would want to hear about things like color, perspective, mood etc. There's the whole other area of Poser technical minuttia, where to put lights, camera focal length, etc. that people may want advice on and is important, but I don't necessarily see that as "artistic" criticism. At any rate, i have no atristic pretentions or aspirations, just trying to think of ways to attack one of Renderosity's perennial complaints. As it stands, few people have the time, inclination or even necessarily the skills to give the kind of feedback people are asking for so why not make it a deliberate, focused process. I'm sure it's no panacea but the current system seems to be broken for many people.

"Democracy is a pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance." - H. L. Mencken