I think it's a matter of mood - or the mood you want to portray. To me, these two images are completely different - even though the same subject material. Neither one, to me, is a "photograph of a tree" - they're both "photographs of a feeling or mood". What i like about the first one: To me, it says "I'm on my own - I'm flying solo". Typically, I don't care for skies without interest - but in this case, it drives the point home. The is no question as to what the subject of this photo is - and it sends a message that i think everyone can associate with. What i like about the second one: I states strength - superiority over the other smaller trees within the composition. This image also gives me more of a feeling of closeness and "protected", if you will. The large image of the tree looks more like a guardian - something you can rely on - in complete control of its destiny. I guess the point I'm trying to make is - neither shot is "better" than the other - depends on the context of the meaning of the photo. If I were looking for a shot to depict the feeling of the Great Depression, something that illustrated an individual against a hard, cruel world - I would have to say the first shot captures that concept perfectly. On the other hand, if I were looking for a shot that depicts "solid, reliable, "you can count on me" sort of concept - the second shot gives me that feeling in spades. Bottom line - given my current mood - I'm more into the first shot....tomorrow, I may like the second! Both are excellent - but I don't think anyone can really say one is any better than the other. Wolf