basse, On some levels we may understand what you are saying but it is not coming across very well... And no matter what this would boil down to what is art/pure because that is what you are judging. I can only judge art on how it affects me; This changes over time and from time to time. One person's piece may be awesome one day/month/year to it's nice another day/month/year, which in turn may be back to awesome the next day/month/year. I guess what it really boils down to is whether you judge art on a technical level or an emotional level. I don't think I can judge art on a technical level, because when I say "wow, that is awesome!" it is effecting me on an emotional level.