Forum: Bryce


Subject: Is leaving a rude comment a Critic??

SNAKEY opened this issue on Feb 08, 2004 ยท 52 posts


SylvieB92 posted Sun, 08 February 2004 at 5:07 PM

Attached Link: http://www.image-in-air3d.com

?????!!!!!! An impolite comment because I wrote that I found excessive to see a commonplace image in Hot20 with 20 or 25 comments "excellent" while those of true good artists have it only 4 or 5???? In what was my message impolite??? Please, well read again it because I believe that you did not very well seize the sense of my papers. What I regret (and this is not for me because I always had very good comments), it is that, for several months, I noticed that was enough resources of good friends to be propelled to the rank of the best artists. Do you find it normal??? Next to that, you have very good images, realized by artists who put only very rarely comments, who meet themselves only with 4 or 5 comments, sometimes even criticisms on behalf of those that put "excellent" on inferior images. Then yes, I find that it is a pity, and that, in these conditions, art is not recognized any more as such, but in the fault of the relations which one can have. Please, if you want help somebody, make tutorials, give advices, but it is not by persuading him (her) that what it makes is excellent that you will help him (her). Indeed, why to make efforts because one says to me that I am excellent??? I believe that all, you did not absolutely understand what I wanted to express. On the other hand, I am anxious to indicate that this excellent person, so sweet, when one puts her comments which are not positive, sends back us very aggressive messages! While my initial message was not absolutely aggressive, I gave only my opinion. Now, if the possibility of commenting on images is made only to say " Wooow, it is beautiful, it is great, artistic, made magnificently ", say it and that only these comments are authorized, it was necessary to clarify it before. Where is freedom of expression in that case? Is it always necessary to put positifs comments and ever to say what does not go to the system???? My comment was no agressive and not tactless, and, in fact, did not even address this person. It addressed especially to the persons who put wrongly positive comments, this to point out to them that next to it, they abandoned those that deserved it really. I have myself a 2 and 3D community, with a forum, In which I make maximum to help the beginners.I spent there days and nights (and I continue to make iy) to bring all that a person who begins needs. I think very sincerely that it is like that that one helps somebody who needs advices, by acting. And certainly not by calling him (her) that what he makes is magnificent. And, please, take a look to the others images, even though these persons do not post you comments. And I repeat that this is not for me, because, each time, I had very good comments. How do you want that one takes a gallery seriously if all the good comments go only to the images of the beginners, while abandoning beautiful creations??? Please...Be just, honest and help really those that need it with true helps, and not with words which put to sleep. Sincerely. (excuse me for my bad English, I am French, and write in English is difficult for me. But I hope that you will understand that I wrote) SylvieB92.