Hi Matt
I understand your feelings on this, and I like your summation:

"Think about what you are commenting on and WHY you are commenting on it. Think about not giving and image an "Excellent!" if you don't believe it deserves it. Think about leaving "helpful comments for improvement" if you think they are valid...But most of all don't feel the need to comment on other peoples work just because you are afraid of not getting any comments the next time you upload an image."

It's a valid point.

For the other part, this is a community, as everyone here is more than willing to help each other out in some way or another. There is a lot of great information here, and it's a friendly atmosphere. You posted your opinions, and others have posted theirs. Isn't that a community?

My suggestions:
When uploading an image, specifically ask for honest opinions, rather than comments. If you don't agree with the rankings, simply don't use them. There are a number of members who don't allow them, and that is their option.

Cliques happen everywhere. It's a fact of life, and there is nothing to stop that.

I thank you for posting your thoughts on this, and I hope this discussion can remain peaceful.

Have a good night everyone.

Nick

Nick C. Sorbin
Staff Writer
Renderosity Magazine
......................................................................................................
"For every breath, for every day of living, this is my Thanksgiving."
-Don Henley