Ok Luigi, you defined some criteria that makes an image - but could you please define what is "good" there and "not so good"? In objective terms, not your personal opinion. I think this will be an endless discussion about nothing really. My position here is exactly as miden1138 said it. Nearly no word to add really. Only that, if Renderosity keeps the ranking system, there are two modifications i would like to see. #1 - back to the old principle that each given ranking is related to the name who gave it. Makes it clearer and everybody sees who has voted how. And the cowards who hide themselves in crowds are easier identified. #2 - The option that i can decide wether my image can be voted to the Hot20 or not. At the moment i can decide about ranking or comments but not about voting. I would love that. But all in all - don't take all this too serious. The discussion about "good" and "not so good" is as old as art is. We will not solve it here! We are even probably not able to solve the issue what good taste is and bad! But we can talk about fairness, helpfullness and considerateness! That is my theme in that context. Walther

One day your ship comes in - but you're at the airport.