If I'm not mistaken, this is the Poser forum, right? The place to exchange experiences, ideas, comments and to help each other, right? That Involves having an opinion about a product, positive or negative. It's definately within the scope of this forum. Renderosity has turned extremely commercial lately. If that means that you will go to any lengths to protect your merchants against the evil customers, you're on a very dangerous path. Customers has every right to exchange information about products in the applicable forum. That includes positive and negative statements. Censorship of product comments is just ridiculous. You are not doing the community a service by having such an attitude. Remember that it's the customers, not the merchants, who pays the bills here.