GOT IT!! It was definitely some kind of corrupt .OBJ file. When I took a look at it in UV Mapper it appeared at a way different angle or orientation than the texture map would seem to imply, a perspective from far above looking down or something rather than straight on from the side. All the other clothing items mapped correctly as you'd expect them to, so it was just something with those ones that for some reason had the map oriented all wrong. Thanks for the help everyone.. the tip about UV Mapping set me in the right investigative direction!