The ones I did are in photoshop layers, and I used layer styles to do all effects. That way, any of the colors can easily be changed to fit different subjects. The posted image is about 2/3 larger then what I'd recommend using. Again, ANY good ideas or better icons are encouraged! There's no way we can get everyone to agree on something like this, but if we can get a large number of people happy with a base idea, it can always be adapted by others. Keeping the base style I feel is important though, to make it easily recognizable to all. We can even have a suggested location on main product images as well, to again make them easier to locate and use.

Way too many people take way too many things way too seriously.