I do not believe the comment was intended to be offensive, but perhaps I am missing something in the translation: "Happy Birthday Rachel!!!!! Nice abstract!!! asta nu e fotografie pretene... " Our interpretation of "Photography" is continually evolving. The Rules at the top of the Gallery state: "This gallery is for Renderosity members to display their original photographs for review, critique and feedback from other Renderosity members. Please use your judgement when uploading photo manipulations and photographs that have been heavily changed. Images containing 2D elements, stock photography or 3D elements should be uploaded to the Mixed Medium or 2D galleries." In my opinion, it is correct to call this a Photograph. Happy Birthday, Rachel.