Forum: Bryce


Subject: Constructively criticism or not? (inspired by DC's message in this forum)

Wahnfried1959 opened this issue on Oct 10, 2004 ยท 28 posts


alvinylaya posted Mon, 11 October 2004 at 4:45 PM

@ Stefano - Nice to see you back buddy! Here are my 2 pennies: WIPs - are great tools for learning for artists like us who are learning; and aren't we all learning? I personally don't post WIPs but I do solicit critique via email to certain members of this community. Honest constructive criticism is one of the most valuable learning tool available in this community. If you want IMs only simply disable "allow comments" and ask for IMs. If you check "allow comments" both praise and critiques WILL inevitably be included, that's just the way it is. It hurts sometimes especially when you worked so hard on something or waited so long for a render but I think of it as necessary pain. This is true for other arts I have taken (martial arts and music), nobody's born a skilled or trained. Nasty/destructive/demeaning/TOS violating comments - theyr'e just a B1+cH! Unfortunately the best thing we can do right now is complain to AS or one of the mods. Complaining to AS ain't that bad, besides he's used to it ;-) Also, I wish people who give crticism have their own gallery (as a sign of good faith) also it helps the receiver of the criticism to judge whether or not to listen or ignore the criticism. Personally I'm more likely to pay attention to critiques from people I know, or people who