cagewench,
As I told LornaW, Rosity has a different purpose than CGTalk, where technical wizardry is the be all and emotion is a secondary thing. A lot of images are very close to us on a personal level (CGTalk doesn't have memorial images for example) and so critique is something that should be requested, rather than inferred. Along time ago, right after 9/11, people were posting many touching images at whatever level they were at, to express their grief. And there were people critiquing them as any picture. I thought that kind of rude. I think if you want critique, it's a simple matter of asking. If someone puts in their description, "Please tell me what's wrong with this picture." Then I am far more inclined to do more of an analysis to see if I can offer a suggestion. If they don't, I respect that as well.

Glad to see someone else had the same thought about the Top 100...

ShadowWind