looniper... Sounds like a good idea. But I have done this in the past. As well as a couple people I know have done the same thing. Even when I gave crits/comments that were not rude I would get IMs inreturn telling me how wrong I was to leave a comment like that. When a bad pic has 30 comments of "Great Work! This is wonderful", then one honest one with a crit, it sticks out like a sore thumb. I have even gotten IMs from people OTHER than the artist whose work I left the comment on. Bashing me. While I am all for Honesty around here at R (since it seems many here are not in comments), I dont see that as having any effect on the h20 voting. -B