I guess I looked at it and couldn't tell what was actually in the plate mail. Looked like another troll (or freak char). As to size, the one on the left appears to be in the background more, therefore, his size, if moved to the foreground would be the same. Hence, my prediction on the winner. Crushing blow notwithstanding, it takes quite a bit of energy to get that heavy ball in motion (making it somewhat easier to dodge). As I understand it, weapons were mch heavier than we assume...dbl handed swords weighing in from 40-60 pounds (I think I read somewhere).