Soultaker, I think you gave a very well-balanced critique. If the artist can't take that kind and helpful a suggestion, they should not check the comments box. It's hard when you've put a lot of work into a piece and get something like "piece of crap!" But your comment was on the money-- and I say this whether I agree with it or not, since I haven't even seen the work. Artists are touchy about their "babies"-- heck I am to the highest degree and sometimes I'll indicate that in the comments. But it would help them to know this and refrain from checking boxes if they don't want to hear anything but "Excellent!! MORE, MORE, MORE!!". Emily