I think they all mean the second cropped image.I had to comment because every one of my shots here are cropped from huge files.I enlarge it to 100% and then use the navigator to hunt down my crop.Of course that's always a horizontal crop,which explains alot if you've seen my work.It also explains the graininess, LOL. I hate to disagree with everyone here especially because you have quite an esteemed group here that commented.But I like the original.I would just come in a little closer,not as tight as your two crops, but a little less info than the original.Just my 2 cents.Either way like the image a lot.:)

Marlene <")

Marlene S. Piskin Photography
My Blog

"A new study shows that licking the sweat off a frog can cure depression. The down side is, the minute you stop licking, the frog gets depressed again." - Jay Leno