Patti has clearly got the wrong end of the stick here! my posting wasnt a personal attack at all, or intended public humiliation, far from it.

"Patti, you are not being attacked here"!

the dedication image from coolbreezylady WAS lovely but it still didnt acknowledge the flames origins!
I did include other examples from other artists in my initial query.

If coolbreezylady wants to bow out thats her standing but im sincerely not asking for that of her or anyone, judging by the i.m. ive been getting that would mean over half the fractal community should bow out!!!

my question to the community was and still is a genuine query not an attack.

I re-iterate :- 'All im asking is, is it wrong for other fractalist to get credit for flame renders they have made from MrP's flames without acknowledging where originaly they came from?'

So, to the community, what is your opinion?

Stefano