End of your line, not mine. Oh, I'm sure you'd love it to be by email (a constant suggestion by you to everyone who has protested your actions) - anything to brush your transgression under the carpet. I never said you were a thief, I said you were a selfish, thoughtless git. You may be generous, but when it's with other people's stuff it's way out of order. It doesn't need a degree in social psychology to know you should ask before using something beyond permission given. That's a basic of life, not just Renderosity forums. "...perhaps my idea of personal use is to apply it to a mesh I'm working on, then distribute that modified mesh." That says a lot about you. If you had just apologised to Kozaburo, I wouldn't have given this thread a second glance.