Forum: Photography


Subject: " straight & constructive comments "

tofi opened this issue on Jul 26, 2006 ยท 24 posts


odie posted Thu, 27 July 2006 at 11:52 AM

I am so glad people are speaking their minds here. I'd like to put in my 3.5 cents, too. My Dad used to say the squeaky wheel gets the most oil. I'd have to say that applies to this place, too. The people getting most of the comments are probably the same ones that jump from upload to upload commenting on each one. Because of this trend I believe Rosity has become more of a popularity contest than a place to come for critique. I realize that the value of each image is a matter of opinion. If you want an image in your gallery, you should upload it. Not everyone will agree with you on the reasons for the upload and that is the beauty of personal art. But when people are expected to hop from image to image just to make an appearance or to leave a non-committal comment, then I start to wonder why I'm here. What bothers me is that there are talented people that feel overlooked. I think it is our obligation to browse the galleries (when we can!) with the attitude that perhaps someone would like to know how to get better. If they don't want constructive criticism, they better check that box! I have actually asked for constructive criticism and then gotten a message that it was distracting to them! LOL You can't win, but sometimes, maybe I WANT to distract you so you'll tell me how to get better. We should all start to appreciate each other's opinions more and put aside the egos that cause people to lash out when they get a constructive criticism. Now that we have the choice of critical and NON critical comments I hope we can use them to everyone's benefit. Thanks for listening. Now help me be a better photographer!! HUGS to you that visit me. I so appreciate your ideas. Jodie

I kid-proofed my house but they STILL get in!!