"Renderosity people are sooooooooo  picki pikci....."

LOL!!. No, not trying to be picky, just trying to help.

If the proportions are correct, then the object looks better 'cos people recognise objects more by their proportions than by their actual shape (although both are used in the recognition process)...

Consider the differences between a coffee-table, a cafe-table and a dining table.

Even taken in isolation, with nothing else in the scene to provide scale, people would usually be able to descriminate between the three. 'Cos the proportions are different..:-))

Cheers,
Diolma