Forum: Community Center


Subject: Rules unclear and unfair

Primal opened this issue on Oct 23, 2006 · 732 posts


CaptainJack1 posted Tue, 24 October 2006 at 11:03 PM

Quote - Okay, i agree, this is pervert. But we are talking here about a image which shows Aiko nacked. Not porn. A nudity image. Whith a toon character.

For the record, my personal opinion is that a nude image of Aiko (not morphed, I'm not sure what positions you could twist her into) doesn't constitute porn. The word "porn" itself has a vague definition of course, that tends to vary from person to person, but that's my opinion. It's entirely possible that, if I were to see the image in question, I might disagree with the judgment as to the apparent age of the character. Note that this is the only problem with the image. No one decided it was "porn", no one decided it was "offensive". The apparent age of the character was judged, the value was too low based on previously defined criteria, and that was that.

It's also my opinion that it would be nice if everyone's art could always be displayed here. The reality of it is, of course, is that it can't. There are some images that are unacceptable, this unacceptability is based on the judgment of a team of people applying a set of rules as best they can, and that's the way it goes.

I don't object to the rules, nor do I object to the way the rules are enforced. However, I absolutely, unequivocally support primaltruck's (and every other member's) right to disagree with me and to disagree with the status of his images here at Renderosity.

My only objection is to the behavior of someone who appears to see no viewpoint but his own, who seems to think that his opinion constitutes a kind of natural law, and throws a fit in a public forum. Temper tantrums are unsightly coming from three year olds; from people who are ostensibly adults, it's downright distasteful. Again, this is my opinion; yours may differ.

It's possible to disagree with a decision in a civil manner, and it's possible for a person to go on a self-absorbed rant, and any number of states in between. I saw in the beginning of this thread behavior that tends toward the former end of the spectrum, and (honestly, against my better judgement) I felt compelled to comment. I'm sure that there are readers of this forum that are at least as annoyed by my behavior as I am by the start of the thread. I suppose, at the least, we can be happy with the fairness of that. 😄