rreynolds opened this issue on Nov 08, 2006 · 57 posts
xoconostle posted Sat, 11 November 2006 at 11:53 AM
Quote - I didn't attack him.
You characterized his character in a poor light in a manner that was more opinionated than "factual." I don't necessarily disagree with what you wrote, but without intending to look for a fight or anything so serious, noted the hypocritical irony of the fact that you so needlessly laid into dphoadly, invoking the mothers' adage "don's say anything at all" while being unpleasant on the interpersonal level yourself. dphoadly merely expressed a (common) opinion about the Millennium figures. There was no "hate," there were no politics. Your response to dphoadly's impersonal remark was barely shy of a personal attack, totally unprovoked, thus, who are you to say "if you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all." Do you imagine that you come across as "nice" when responding like that?
Quote - I gave him props for his excellent technical work. I merely stated facts posted over and over again by himself in the forums.
As your postings in this thread are my evidence, you went beyond facts stated by Anton himself into critical opinion. You completely mischaracterized dphoadly's opinion. > Quote - Please point out what I posted that was not actual historical information, and easily tracable in the various forums.
The subject is not Anton's behavioral history. My comment, which I'd hoped the winky emoticon would make clear was only intended as friendly ribbing, was simply "you might want to think twice about throwing bricks from glass houses."