i think this is the same dead horse as recording music with either digital or analog means...if you didn't know which one you were hearing you probably couldn't guess; if they were recorded correctly/professionally.

i didn't see you pic because it didn't show up for me. 
so with that in mind, if just pop a poser figure over a background and take a render and then post that pic...then it will probably look like it. there can be as much art inputted into a good poser scene as there would be with creating one from scratch...though with poser you are cheating somewhat. but who cares?
purist's.
that's fine, let the purist's think they are holy. if you create from scartch you are definately talented. 
but me, i think i'll cheat and still create some good art work.

oh and by the way...way to keep your head while the other guy was flaming; you scored lot's of points by that.

Comitted to excellence through art.