I agree with Maxfield....    I was going to suggest to try on getting that look with some work in Poser and lots of post work.....   You might get a combination of effects to give you that VHS look...   but then you have one frame and possibly a few hundreds to go.....   

Your really talking highend equiptment ----OR---- you can give up your VHS look and give up on having your CGI models look exatly like your real friends and then you can do it...  With a lot of patience...  and many visits to this forum...

welcome......

  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------