This Argument is taking on extreams, First off, V3 will not be perfect for everyone, that will be a fact. Some people like more extreams. Personaly I like V3 much better than the correct examples that you displayed. You did a good job of illustraing them, that is not my reasoning. But what is Ideal with you is not nessasly Ideal to me. techniquely you are right. but for personably I also have the same right to have a preference. All that I here is She is not the way that is correct to all the technitions. But who are you or anyone else to say I can't make a figure in the shape that I like best. Says you, thats fine, but I can make a figure the way I want, It's called freedom of expression! or do you want to challange that.
    That's fine. But why do Todays artist make legs longer on a woman than they realy are. Because that is the more desirable look. Shame on them for having a preference. We are not talking about extreams that the mass people don't reconize here, You show the stock figure of V3 with body texture and hair to a person on the street and they may say she is very sexy, pretty, or To beautful, not your average girl. They are not going to say what is it. 
   This is exactly the point everyone is talking about. No wons arguing that your head hights are not well founded. They are the standard you hold true, and the clients you represent. But other company have different standards, are you going to tell me they are wrong for making a characture the way their client find more appealing. Are you suggesting they tell their clients, you don't know what your talking about!

What I say, and what you say, and what anyone else says will never change that. Why do we have liberals and Conservatives, why do we have different religeions, Because we all see things differently. It's the way we want to see them. It's the way different artist express themselves. You should always be aware of correct proportions of the figure. But where does it say you can't make your charatures the way you like them. Wow, Elmer Fudd would have thought someone was taking a cheap shot at him. Where would we be without Elmer Fudd.  We would never have cartoons. It's called lighten up. The world will go on.