Billy,

First, I appreciate your concerns regarding the comments. The answer to your question really is both simple and complex (if that makes the slightest bit of sense). 

Each person is different. I find that out of all the users on Renderosity, the writers actually have a tendency to appreciate frank and constructive criticism far more often than average. This, of course, does not hold true for everyone as egos can be sensitive and easily bruised things. One of the things I've learned on Renderosity and through friendships with those with creative minds is that they tend to have far more sensitive egos than most people. 

So the answer is yes, some people here undoubtedly are only looking for positive words and encouragement. And the answer is no, some people are looking for honest criticism. My recommendation is simply to continue to post your honest impressions in your comments, while keeping in mind that your words can bite unintentionally. Keep your comments constructive, and don't concern yourself with how your thoughts are received.

I went ahead and edited your forum post just to remove the comment you considered to be attacking, simply because I'd prefer to keep things as civil and not directed at any particular person as possible.

David L.
Writer's Forum Moderator