well, I guess it's time to get in my 2 cents... I like them all...but like everyone else, I like combinations of the images...The bottom right has a good shadow for the rocks under the fire...I really like the moon in the bottom right and the top has a really awesome sky. The bottom left seems like there's a little too much light on the mountain...and the other two seem like there's not quite enough. I agree with tradivoro on the fire and the smoke. All three are excellent images! When you ask for opinions you'll get all different kinds from different perspectives. Take all the advice into your thought process and do what you like the best...it's your creation after all. Jared