From what I read in the sticky, it looks like you are going to control the art charts. So it looks like your back to the original post in a round about way. You will critique each other and get your images into the top ranks. Not much different than having all the friends, is it.

I would think that if you are going to use the excuse of being critique, maybe you should have a special gallery that does not use the post/view count. Then again, maybe that is the whole plan to get these images in the top ranks. I'm confussed, what's the difference between the populars and the Critiques now?