I think this is a fantastic idea; I would love to be able to give constructive criticism without worrying that I might offend someone who didn't wish for a critique (and conversely let people know that it is open season on my own images). I do have a problem with the current execution of the critique club. Well, I'm just basically too lazy to hunt down images from a "favorites" list or e-bot notices. I would much rather have a specific gallery, where I could go and know that any image posted there is open for honest critique. I am much more likely to post comments to a greater variety of images and artists this way. Plus, with a special critique gallery, I can choose to NOT post an image to that gallery. To me it is important to have the choice to keep some piece of fluff I post out of the line of fire. Do we all really want honest critique on every image we post? :unsure: