Good idea ! "the critique club" !
Only good comments is cool but no constructive.
We all want good comments, but sometimes "bad" critics are very important to enhance works in progress of future works.

when I work on a scene, i ask my wife and friends to give their impresions about it
(ambience, colors, what they think is it about…)

Sometimes, I hear things like " it's cool, but what is it for ?" did you hear the same things ?

do you think that someone whose looking at a Picasso painting, would say to him
" it's cool, but what is it for ?"

art is something very strange ! 3D is very very strange if you think to all the possibilities !

excuse me for my english, it's probably approximative

if you need a french guy, i'm in ! i'll try to translate for french users of bryce  who have problems with english language.

Amigafreak from France

Imac G5 - 1,8 Ghz - 1,25 Go ram - bryce 5 - Poser 5
Imac G3 - 500 Mhz - 384 Mo ram - bryce 5 (don't laugh, it works !)