As a complete novice in Photography, I would certainly appreciate honest critique and suggestions- I need the input to get better, but I am not getting it.

Unfortunately the culture here (and I am also guilty of it, I will admit) has become a bit of a scratch your back, scratch mine. I think a combination of the competitive nature of "most commented, most viewed, etc.." might have some relevance in the culture shift.  Sure, its always been here in one shape or another, but now it is in your face on the home page- forced to view.

Coming from the 3D realm initially (Poser, Lightwave, Vue) I see this all the time- artwork that comes from those that pat the back of everyone else, despite their own content, gets huge ratings and hits because people feel obligated to return the favor. One artist in particular comments on every render with "Fantastic Work!!!!!!" or something similar (no comment on content or anything) and receives massive return adulation, despite the repeated common theme for every one of their works. Like a template machine bent on receiving ratings- with no regard for true commentary on other artists works.

In other words, its like a popularity contest: If you give everyone possible a pat on the back, the return investment is huge ratings on your work. 

I noticed a huge drop off in views and comments on Photographs I posted vs. nude renders from Poser. Sex sells, even if its digital mannequins.

I do not think there is much a few can do to steer the rampaging cattle- but one good comment or suggestion can really help another artist or photographer. So, while I see no solution at hand, I do think that taking the time to set the example and comment honestly will help some. 

Also, I think another contributing factor to the "hug club" is the fear of offending someone. With so many cultures represented here, and language barriers inherent to an internationally populated site, people are hesitant to offer critique.  One would hope that we are all adults here, but living in the real world we know this is certainly not the case. 

Just my two cents, and a plea for the experienced photographers out there reading this to take a quick gander at my few recent photographs and tell me what I can do to improve.  Unfortunately at this stage, my personal experience is not at a level that I could offer critique or helpful advice in the realm of Photograhy- I could at least comment on the aesthetics of an image or the technical quality.