heyas; they appear to be different, to me. the yellow ribbon tassel things, and the rear strap could have been added on.... however, the main girth strap appears to be a different shape. the stirrups do as well, although it is hard to tell from the angle of the second image. the stirrup straps are different. the base seat part is built differently. the horn shapes are similar; the cantle is taller in the second than the first. the bridle/rein and english saddle also look different than the ones that jackie creaated (and i modified). in my professional opinion, they are newly built models. :)