At viper - I think jinet is the best at constractive crit. he is honest and realy knows what he's talking about. the thing about art is it's still gotta follow rules, painting, drawing, photography all of those. and if a photographer meaningfully over exposed a photo for effect they need to state why in their text and what the perpose of that was so that we who like to comment can understand the 'art' much better.

plus most ppl over expose or puch the editing too far ad are to scared to admit failure are that they are still learning.

you've gotta comment on what you see to your eye and if you don't like it say so and why.

if you submit a pic to a photo mag for crit the first things they look at are compo, exposure, thirds, other rules and technical areas and last interest of pic. coz the picture can be as boring as shit but if all the photographic skills are mastered and colours are exposive then those could be the factors that turn the whole shot around...

Rights Come With Responsibilities VAMP'hotography Website VAMP'hotography Blog