That is not exactly what I am saying Gert. I am not sure what to classify Renderosity as, but perhaps entry level art gallery is appropriate. All I can say is that there are all different sorts of people here for many different reasons. For some, it is to be social. Does that make it wrong? No, but it may not be what you want out of it. Believe me, i am frustrated with comments that are non-constructive as well. To be clear, just because a comment is all positive, does not mean it is isn't constructive. But a generic "love it" doesn't really do much either. I only suggest that if you wish to get constructive critique on an image, make it clear and be specific. There is a work in progress gallery but is underutilized and a bit to broad in my opinion. I think most people posting images feel that they have reached a point where they can proudly put it in their gallery, whether that is truly the case or not. So I think they view other's work in the same light. If you can think of a way to get people to put more thought critique into their comments, I'm all ears. Until then, I think you have to make it very clear when you post your image that you are looking for helpful feedback, or post it in the Forum in a thread like the Constructive Critique. If you know of any web sites that only criticially review posted works, I think we'd like to hear about them.

Kort Kramer - Kramer Kreations