KarenJ opened this issue on Mar 21, 2007 · 1211 posts
Tiari posted Sun, 15 April 2007 at 12:50 PM
I haven't posted on this thread in a while, but I have been dilligently posting comments on every piece that rolls in and is uploaded, with few execptions. Though I try to be helpful, I realize at times my honesty might be a bit too much, but so far no complaints. I did want to make anyone aware, I do try to help if I think i can with a suggestion. I have seen a lot of good work thrown off by something "amiss" ....... thats just "odd.". Usually that minor change can make the difference.
I do have a concern, however. I have been very hesitant to post my feelings, as it might be taken wrong, but it is so engrained in me now, I really feel I should say something. In several images I have looked at and gotten ebot messages of a new image, there is a lot of description of "Just threw this up"......."Just wanted to get something up today". Its no specific entity, but names showing up with ebot alerts, over and over, then to see "Just playing with my new item".
Now, I'm not saying people can't do that, its fun of course, and thats fine. However, it is sort of wasteful to walk on over to critique something that was "thrown together". Do you see what I mean? Maybe something else in the description to note it doesnt require an artistic critique would be helpful.