KarenJ opened this issue on Mar 21, 2007 ยท 1211 posts
alanpfd posted Mon, 14 May 2007 at 10:59 PM
Just curious about how people are using the critique group. Say you've posted an image and have received a ton of helpful critiques. Do you take the information and apply it to your next image or do you go back and re-work the original image? If you re-work the image, how do you post it? Do you edit the original image and replace it with the new and improved or do you post the improved image anew? I've seen a lot of people respond to critiques in their own comments, but it seems to me unlikely that the original critic will be back to see the comment. I wonder if there is a way to make the critiquing process more of a dialogue. Obviously the surest way to get further feedback is to post the improved image as a new image, but then you have two similar images in your gallery and if you delete the original image, you lose all of your comments. I wish there was a way to trigger an ebot when you update an image. Anyway, I'm curious how others are dealing with this. -Alan