Forum: Poser - OFFICIAL


Subject: Want critiques?

KarenJ opened this issue on Mar 21, 2007 · 1211 posts


FutureFantasyDesign posted Thu, 17 May 2007 at 5:17 PM

Can I add a little request? I notice that in some threads there are no links to either post location/pics and I can't tell myself what is being referred to.   The post was by MissNancy on page two... I did not see a link, and have no idea of where to look or what the image is.

Comment:

"o.k., it appears plenty of folks are interested in our very helpful opinions, so let the fun begun!
I already spotted one good image for criticism. it was actually linked as an example
of what the artist would like to emulate, but the linked image in question had a number of
problems IMVHO:

no facial expression
pasted over a blurred generic photoshop background
a flat render with no depth
stiff pose
poor or no shadows
kinky poser hair in desperate need of retouching
no background props or scene composition
edge-framing detracts from image, makes it appear even flatter
identical reflection map in both eyes
headband filigree prop appears pasted over render
appears to use nostril-plug props or dark nostril colour (but I could be wrong)

however, the render in question is far better than most of the poser stuff there IMVHO.
I like it meself. the technical details are not gonna be of any interest to the casual
viewers, hence any criticism of this type will have little effect in real terms."

Was this meant to be retorical or did  the link disappear? Sorry I just became a bit confused. I also see that if the image link was posted, it would be easier than going to each and every person's gallery on the list. So that being said, if there is an image you want input on, you post it here (*the link) and then it is easier to track the info. IMHO

Karen do you suggest the critique be in this thread or on the image comment section? I am a bit unclear on that too.

ThanX!

Ariana 

Is there water in your future or is it being shipped away to be resold to you?
Water, the ultimate weapon...

www.futurefantasydesign.com