mmmm... may be we are not looking at the real problem ! ...

Who want real critics ? I mean real artistic and technical critics !

Why not just create a sticky topic, where we can put name of members who really want it ?

Or just put a line in you post with your pic, with an acronym like ICACC (i can assume contructive critic).

Here in photography, i see three groups : the 'i want to progress' group, the 'say hello to my cat/dog/baby' group, the 'i just want good comments from my friends' group.

So, if you feel you want to progress in photography, just take the right group.

And if you want a real progression but not elitist, why not comment with contructivism in mind, not just the good pic, but the average or bad one too !
So in this way, everybody will progress (.. i hope lol)

But i think we are a minority :o( 

So now.. define the goal and shoot !

Seeya
Olivier