XENOPHONZ opened this issue on Mar 14, 2008 · 40 posts
XENOPHONZ posted Mon, 17 March 2008 at 6:49 PM
No apologies needed -- you didn't "offend" me in the sense that I think you mean, nor did you "touch a nerve". As I attempted to explain in my last post: when it comes to men like Lee and Grant, you've got to look at the whole man -- and not just at one or two aspects of their personal character. There's a lot to them. You also have to consider those men in the historical context of their own times -- which is precisely the point where many modern-day commentators miss the boat entirely. There's a present-day tendency to judge historic figures by today's standards: standards which are often informed by modes of thought & experience which would have been utterly alien to the people who were actually alive during that period of history. By no means am I saying that's what you are doing: but I've seen many examples of the practice.
In any case: what I am intending here is nothing more than the beginning of an action-adventure fantasy story with a historic backdrop for a stage. As others have already pointed out, mixing real history into a story is a very common motif in modern scifi: and it's a motif which I personally enjoy playing around with. However, it's handy (and fun, IMO) to know a little background about actual events, and from differing points of view. So thanks for the input! But I'll add the thought that I am not planning on getting bogged down in a running debate about the real history of the Civil War -- the main thing that I'm doing here is taking a little stab at historical science fantasy......with all that the term "fantasy" entails.
Fantasy can be sheer time-off-from-the-daily-grind fun. And that's the intent here.