Hey, silverblade, let it all out! :biggrin:

I haven't tried all the apps you mention so I can only compare from what I've heard.
I've briefly tried demos of ZBrush & Mudbox. The UI of ZBrush was definitely made by someone who doesn't understand the importance of an intuitive interface. I was impressed with Mudbox.
I also had a brief look at Max, but I could tell I would need to spend alot of time with this app to get used to it. I used to use Bryce years ago & loved it until I found Vue.
You're right, Vue isn't perfect, but for the price it's one of the best there is. It has good Poser import, great interior & exterior scene possibilities. You can make pretty much any type of render you can think of, I can't think of another app that can do this for the price.
If I was to give advice to a total newbie who wanted to get into 3D I would recommend Vue. It might be a bit daunting at first, but once you get used to it the UI is a doddle, easy on the eye & easy to use. Why some apps insist on a crazy interface is beyond me.
But I know, you do get used to them after a while.
I have Hex 2 now. I just need to find the time away from Vue to give it a go!

I think you summed it up best when you said Vue is the best compromise. I really think it is.