michaeldonnelly1963 opened this issue on May 09, 2008 · 36 posts
bclaytonphoto posted Sat, 10 May 2008 at 7:29 AM
"As I previously stated I wasn't making a personal criticism just making an observation"
let's be real here OK? it was personal..To say it wasn't ..just isn't being truthful.
as for a rule about not subg stock photo's...That's overstating the obvious isn't it? If the majority of the members want's a line added about that..fine easy enought to do that..
Non-competitive...we've been there and discussed this previously..That is why we have two challenges per month..
The entire point of two challenges..is this..the forum challenge is less formal..you can post a comment in the thread about the images posted..The Genre Challenge is more formal..more rules..
If the images are posted to the gallery..then it defeats the purpose of commenting in the forum thread..it could be dome that way..but it seems pointless to me.. besides then it is no longer annonymous..we discussed this previously and the members perfer it to be annonymous.
Voting..voting can be done right on the challenge page..and let an automated system tally the votes in an un-weighted manner..We used do run it this way..
But, we had a few ties..and back in the older days of Rendo..This is how we used to do voting...
There is less of a chance of a tie..I showed the members this option..then voted and decided this is what they prefered.
Voting for the next subject..been there done that one too..doesn't work..getting people to make a clear cut decision in a given time fram edoesn't happen..