**David Archuleta sang Think of Me. Brooke White sang something from Evita, I believe. Jason Castro did a song from Cats. And I can't remember what Syesha Mercado did, but it was from another of his musicals, not Phantom. IMO, Music of the Night stole the entire show that night. Just type  in the contestants name and Andrew Lloyd Webber together and you should be able to find them all.

On a side note, I went looking for the original songs (at youtube) after it was listed what each was doing and completely fell in love with both Cats and Phantom. I kept looking for all the originals from each show. grin I'd never heard any of the songs before then and those songs left me with the desire to see the entire show for both of those mentioned. You can also hear the original versions at youtube. Youtube is wonderful for having things like that.
**