Quote - > Quote - Uncanny valley. 

.....see sig line

I spent alot of time thinking about this (and not thoroughly understanding your position) and even though the texture and bump maps look great, for me there's something about the way the eyelids meet the sclera that is really unsettling...that is, of the pics that were posted in this thread...that I was really put off by these images. However that's just my opinion,  my a&&hole.