Well I like the first one better for your purpose but the couch is too detailed and the relative reality of it takes away from the rest. I hate all that the eye is drawn to stuff because it sounds pompous and concieted but in this case; that couch ! ! ! I keep looking at it and can't concentrate on anything else - do something before I go cross eyed !! 

but seriously, the first one. 

(just a gentle reminder - 09/19/08(U.S.) is International "Talk Like a Pirate Day" )